Level 0 Gold dust LOST :( Got a nice little Tepper Fruit Plushie though.

Level the first:

Spectrum Mardi Gras Beads

Lost :p

[/b] Coal Snowball Yellow Snowball Radioactive Snowball Snowball Love Snowball

(Steps 2 through 7 were lost, sadly, because I didn't write them down and the back button only works for one page. However, I got the snowballs again and picked the last option, which was NOT the love snowball, and it worked, thus proving the new theory once again. Also, this was the farthest I've ever gotten with the decanter. Step 8. I got 256 points and a Sun Devonti Elixir)

STEP 8: 100HP Healing Potion [Lost] 25HP Healing Potion 300HP Healing Potion 20HP Healing Potion 40HP Healing Potion

Level 0 Add A Sheet Of: Angelic Toilet Paper Bloodred Toilet Paper Dark Matter Toilet Paper [WON] Poop Toilet Paper Toilet Paper

Level 1 Add A Piece Of Rubber From A: Bloodred Hikei Bouncy Ball Chibi Harvester Bouncy Ball [LOST] Bouncy Telenine Ball Dusk Keeto Bouncy Ball Chibi Endeavor Bouncy Ball

Level 0 Add Of Tuft Of Fake Fur From A: Red Kerubi Tail Blue Kerubi Tail Black Kerubi Tail Green Kerubi Tail [WON] Yellow Kerubi Tail

Level 1 Add A Drop From A: Red Celestial Flask Purple Celestial Flask Blue Celestial Flask Green Celestial Flask [WON] Yellow Celestial Flask

Level 2 Add A Drop Of: Honeysuckle Oil Fishliver Oil [WON] Hyacinth Oil Nutmeg Oil Juniper Oil

Level 3 Add A Spoonful Of: Kiwi Umbrella Drink [LOST] Blueberry Umbrella Drink Raspberry Umbrella Drink Orange Umbrella Drink Wild Berry Umbrella Drink

Level 0 Add A Brush Bristle From A: Mr Paintbrush Jack Cardale Paintbrush [LOST] Colonel Awesome Paintbrush Keith Paintbrush Calvin Blackmoon Paintbrush

Add A Piece of Shell From A/An: Easter Love Egg Dark Matter Easter Egg Bloodred Easter Egg Plain Easter Egg [WON] Angelic Easter Egg

Add A Glob Of Blob From A: Pink Blob Doll Purple Blob Doll Green Blob Doll Blue Blob Doll [LOST] Feli Blob Doll

Sorry I know this isn't much help as I can't name the items I chose, but...

Level 0: chose item and won level 1: chose item and won level 2: chose item and wom level3: chose item and LOST

:)

Also, I've noticed the more often I play the LESS likely I am to go through to the higher levels...

So I think the LESS often you play, the more often you'l get to a higher level...